The Atlantic

Is President Trump’s Immigration Order a 'Muslim Ban'?

Yes. Here’s why.
Source: Carlos Barria / Reuters

Imagine the following scenario.

A new presidential administration announces that “political turmoil and terrorism” in the Middle East requires new immigration rules.

From now on, visitors, immigrants and refugees from Israel will not be admitted.

With one exception, that is—believers in “minority religions” within the Jewish state (this is, most prominently, Christians and Muslims) will be allowed to enter, because they are being persecuted at home.

Accused of anti-Semitism, the new administration is aghast. How could you even suspect that? Look—Jews from elsewhere in the world are free to enter—even from other countries with large Jewish populations! It

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic5 min read
Oil Was Supposed to Rebuild Iraq
In theory, Iraq could raise the estimated $88 billion it says it needs to rebuild the country on its own in less than a year.   In the lead-up to the U.S. invasion of Iraq 15 years ago, one factor in the debate was the notion that the the war would a
The Atlantic9 min readSociety
Michigan State University Is Botching Its Reputation-Rehab
School officials should be following the post-crisis blueprint from Pennsylvania State. Instead, they’re making things worse.
The Atlantic9 min readSociety
Facebook Vigilantism Is a Scary Thing
In early December, a shocking video recorded in the lobby of an apartment building on the outskirts of Beirut surfaced on the internet. The video, posted to an unusual Facebook page called Weynieh el Dawleh—or “Where is the state?”—showed two young m